Natural Gas Weather — Week of November 15, 2026
GFS vs ECMWF Demand-Hub Outlook: 2026-11-15 12:00 UTC
Open-Meteo GFS seamless vs ECMWF IFS 0.25°, 15-day horizon, demand-weighted HDD/CDD at 65°F base. Fetched 21:33 UTC.
Executive Summary
Both models agree on a cold start (Nov 15–17) but diverge sharply thereafter: ECMWF holds a much colder days 5–15 pattern, with weighted 15-day cumulative HDD of 264.0 vs GFS 198.6 — roughly one-third more implied heating load. The gap is concentrated in Chicago and NYC, which carry 65% of the demand weight and explain ~83% of the national divergence. Convergence is low (0.164), and the days 1–6 ECMWF-colder spread of 13.8 HDD is statistically typical for mid-November, meaning most of it reflects the models' usual seasonal bias rather than new information.
Hub-Level Weather
| Hub (weight) | GFS cum HDD | ECMWF cum HDD | Δ (ECMWF–GFS) | Mean abs HDD diff/day |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Midwest / Chicago (0.35) | 254.3 | 329.4 | +75.1 | 5.57 |
| East / NYC (0.30) | 206.8 | 299.7 | +92.9 | 6.88 |
| Northeast / Boston (0.10) | 249.7 | 316.3 | +66.6 | 5.05 |
| South Central / Houston (0.15) | 33.3 (CDD 44.6) | 55.3 (CDD 8.8) | +22.0 HDD / −35.9 CDD | 2.02 |
| South / Atlanta (0.10) | 175.5 | 189.3 | +13.8 | 2.72 |
- Days 1–3 (Nov 15–17): tight agreement. Chicago HDDs differ by ≤1 HDD/day; both models show mean temps in the upper 30s–low 40s °F across the Midwest and East.
- Days 4–9 (Nov 18–22): GFS turns milder. GFS lifts Chicago into the mid-50s °F by Nov 19–21 (HDD 8–10/day) and NYC to 54–56°F Nov 21–23; ECMWF stays 3–6°F cooler with HDDs 13–19/day in the East.
- Days 9–11 (Nov 23–25): the core divergence. ECMWF drives a cold shot — Chicago mean temps 33.3–35.1°F (HDD 29.9–31.7/day) and NYC 32.5–35.4°F (HDD 29.6–32.5/day) vs GFS in the mid-40s °F. This lands Mon–Wed of Thanksgiving week.
- Late window: partial reconvergence, then a second split. Boston and Chicago re-converge by Nov 28, but NYC Nov 27–28 shows GFS at ~59°F (HDD 5.6–5.7) vs ECMWF 47–49°F (HDD 16–18).
- Houston is a directional flip. GFS produces 44.6 CDD (Nov 19–26, peaking at 7.5 on Nov 26) and closes the window at 71.5°F on Nov 29; ECMWF limits CDD to 8.8 and ends at 49.7°F (15.3 HDD) — a 21.8°F single-day gap, the largest in the dataset.
Demand Implications (Natural Gas)
- The national picture is heating-dominated: weighted CDD is negligible in both solutions (GFS 6.7, all Houston; ECMWF 1.3). The demand story is entirely natural gas resi/heat load.
- The 65.5 weighted-HDD gap between solutions is the key risk: if ECMWF verifies, implied heating load over the window runs ~33% above the GFS solution — a materially colder demand scenario for NG balances, with the Nov 23–25 cold shot the single biggest driver of incremental burn and storage draw (see EIA storage).
- Under GFS, demand fades quickly after Nov 22 (East HDDs drop to 5–12/day late-month) and Houston adds modest cooling load — a much softer pull profile.
- Atlanta is the closest-agreed hub (Δ13.8 HDD), so the Southeast demand signal is comparatively well constrained.
Model Agreement & Caveats
- Convergence is low: 0.164 (weighted mean abs HDD diff 5.09 HDD/day). Treat days 1–4 as the reliable signal and days 5–15 as two distinct scenarios rather than a consensus. The ECMWF cold shot is the low-confidence element.
- Spread significance (status "ok," days 1–6): today's ECMWF-colder spread is 13.81 HDD (ECMWF 93.27 vs GFS 79.47). What is normal for this season is 12.26 HDD — Open-Meteo's ECMWF runs systematically colder from October through February — so today's anomaly is +1.54 HDD (z = +0.30), labeled "typical," with the absolute anomaly at only the 25th percentile of past cycles. In plain terms: the models' gap is slightly wider than the seasonal norm but well within it; most of the raw spread is known bias, not news.
- Verification (status "ok"): across 96 comparable cycles, about 45% of the ECMWF-colder anomaly was realized at the 5-day verification lag — a statistically significant persistence (t = 3.11, p = 0.002, Newey-West lag 5). This describes past windows and is not a backtested forecast; it should not be converted into a corrected HDD figure.
- Run-over-run: the 12Z ECMWF run warmed by ~12.0 weighted HDD vs its 00Z run (CDD −0.22), narrowing the gap to GFS (mean abs diff −0.98; convergence +0.023). No prior GFS cycle was available for comparison.
- Caveats: the GFS 12Z run is flagged not yet ingested in run metadata despite series being present; hubs are single-grid-point proxies at 0.25°; the expected-spread fit is noisy (R² = 0.15, residual SD ≈ 5.1 HDD). The spread-significance score is weather-only — it is not a forecast and says nothing about Henry Hub price direction. See the full weather model comparison for underlying data.