Natural Gas Weather — Week of November 16, 2026

GFS vs ECMWF Demand-Hub Outlook: 2026-11-16 00Z

Executive Summary

Both models open the period cold (Nov 16–17) and then diverge sharply: ECMWF finishes the 15-day window at 237.7 demand-weighted HDD vs GFS at 205.3 — a 32.4 HDD (+15.8%) colder national picture driven mainly by the East. The days 1–6 ECMWF-colder spread of 12.6 HDD is statistically "typical" for mid-November (z = −0.15), so it reads as the models' usual seasonal bias rather than a fresh cold signal. ECMWF trended 26.3 weighted HDD warmer run-over-run, which is the material change that triggered this report.

Hub-Level Weather

Hub (weight) GFS cum HDD ECMWF cum HDD ECMWF − GFS Mean abs daily HDD diff
Midwest / Chicago (0.35) 273.2 289.7 +16.5 2.53
East / NYC (0.30) 199.6 261.0 +61.4 5.01
South Central / Houston (0.15) 72.9 83.0 +10.2 2.28
Northeast / Boston (0.10) 248.6 289.3 +40.7 4.33
South / Atlanta (0.10) 139.9 166.3 +26.4 2.29
  • Cold start, high agreement (Nov 16–17): models are within ~0.4–0.8 HDD/day at every hub; both show 20+ HDD in the Midwest and Northeast.
  • Contested mid-period warm-up (Nov 18–22): GFS is markedly milder in the East — NYC averages ~10.4 HDD/day under GFS vs ~15.2 under ECMWF — and shows genuine cooling demand in Houston (32.2 cumulative CDD, peaking at 7.4 CDD on Nov 22 at 72.4°F, vs 0.4 CDD / 65.4°F for ECMWF).
  • Flipped cold risk (Nov 23–26): ECMWF drives a much colder East Coast surge; the single largest daily gap is NYC on Nov 25 (26.5 vs 10.5 HDD; 38.5°F vs 54.5°F). GFS instead holds its cold for the Midwest at the end of the window (Chicago Nov 30: 28.0 vs 22.4 HDD).
  • The East hubs (NYC + Boston, 0.40 combined weight) account for the bulk of the national model gap.

Demand Implications (Natural Gas)

  • Heating dominates: weighted cumulative CDD is negligible in both models (GFS 4.8, ECMWF 0.8), so the natural gas demand picture is effectively all HDD.
  • ECMWF implies ~15.8% more weighted heating load than GFS over 15 days. The gap is concentrated in the high-weight East: NYC alone contributes a 61.4 HDD cumulative divergence (18.5 weighted HDD).
  • Near term (days 1–6), ECMWF is 12.6 weighted HDD colder (80.3 vs 67.6) — supportive of heating load early, but per the significance scoring below, that gap is not unusual for the season.
  • The demand-relevant uncertainty is timing of the late-month cold: ECMWF's Nov 24–26 East cold shot vs GFS's Nov 28–30 Midwest/East cold changes which days carry peak load, even where totals converge.
  • This is a weather-demand signal only; it says nothing about direction for NG.

Model Agreement & Caveats

  • Convergence: score of 0.228, up 0.052 from the prior cycle — modest agreement that is improving. Models align well through day 2 and diverge materially from day 3 onward (weighted mean abs HDD diff 3.39/day). Lean on the day 1–2 signal strongly; treat 15-day cumulative totals as a wide range.
  • Spread significance (days 1–6, status "ok"): today's ECMWF-minus-GFS spread is 12.65 HDD vs a seasonal expected spread of 13.45 — an anomaly of −0.81 HDD (z = −0.147, 12th percentile), labeled "typical." In other words, the "ECMWF colder" gap is the well-documented Open-Meteo ECMWF cold bias normal from October to February, not new information.
  • Verification (status "ok"): across 95 past cycles, 41.4% of the spread anomaly was realized (SE 0.145, t = 2.851, p = 0.004 — statistically significant at the 5% level). With today's anomaly essentially at zero, this adds little incremental signal. Note the share describes past windows and is not backtested as a forecast — it is not a corrected HDD number.
  • Run-over-run: ECMWF 00Z came in 26.3 weighted HDD warmer (and convergence +0.05) vs its prior 12Z Nov 15 run; no prior GFS cycle was available for comparison. CDD delta (−0.5) is immaterial.
  • Data caveats: the GFS 00Z run is flagged ingested: false at fetch time (08:43Z) despite series being present — treat GFS values with some caution. Underlying data are ~0.25° gridded Open-Meteo fields for five point hubs, two deterministic runs only; see the weather model history for run-over-run context. Degree days use a 65°F base; the convergence score concerns weather agreement, not price.

Arc Research publishes market data and research for information only. It is not investment, trading or financial advice, and Arc Research is not a registered investment adviser or commodity trading advisor. Futures and options trading carries a substantial risk of loss. Hypothetical, backtested and paper results are not actual trading. Read the full disclaimer · Terms of Service · Affiliates